Awesomer than The Fan.

September 17, 2007

Monument Avenue: The last frontier for developers?

Maury Place

Monument Avenue: gorgeous mansions line the street, and the statues that dot the medians make the historic road a hallmark of Richmond. The purely residential feel of Monument Ave is one aspect that sets the street apart from all others. But now, are developers descending upon it looking to cash-in on history?

Pictured above is potentially the first business to open its doors on Monuement west of The Boulevard. The house at 3101 W. Franklin may not technically reside on Monument, but only a grassy median separates it from the Maury statue at the corner of Belmont and Monument. Soon, it will open it’s doors as “Maury Place,” a bed and breakfast.

Some may laud the new business. Let’s face it, hotel chains like the Marriott are exactly in the best part of town. Who wants to stay there? A bed and breakfast could fit in quite well on the residential street. Bringing more tourists to the area could help local businesses. But putting businesses on Monument destroys the very thing that’s appealing about the street - there are virtually no businesses.

Artist Underground Cafe

“Maury Place” wouldn’t be the first business to open its doors on Monument. Recently, “Artist Underground Cafe” opened its doors as a coffee shop and bar at the corner of Monument and Stuart. The cafe is in the basement of an apartment complex there, arguably another business. Richmond Renaissance so far has gotten away with that illegal parking lot as well.

But the line needs to be drawn somewhere. Clearly, when businesses begin to move in, it’s only a matter of time before the 7-11s and Starbucks begin to acquire storefronts on our sacred street. Once commerce begins to creep onto Monument it will be too late to save what made the street great in the first place.

It’s not too late to save Monument Ave. “Maury Place” is still seeking the necessary permits to open up as a bed and breakfast. The City Council must approve the use of residential land for business purposes. If we stay quiet now, it’s only a matter of time until a 7-11 is situated facing the Lee Statue.

 

12 Comments.

  1. Honestly, I wish that half the crappily cared for apartment structures (yes, and some single family dwellings) on Monument looked half as good or offered half the positive potential that this proposed B & B does.

    For those of you easily confused by sensationalist propaganda, I can see how you may confuse a 7-11 with an up scale 2-4 room bed and breakfast; No large parties; No events; Parking available; No signage; Reservations required; No walkin bookings.

    The structure also has enough historical preservation covenants to choke a horse. Moldings must be kept, floor plan must not change, even some of the light fixtures must remain. The level of financial commitment to the property by the owners is HUGE and not one most could afford to take lightly.

    The initial post should have included before pictures as well. All that lovely paint and refurbed window is new. The proposed B&B has actually improved the condition of the property. It is in better condition than it has been in decades thanks to the extensive preservation minded renovations undertaken by the new owner/residents of Maury Place. The new owners will reside in the home from which they hope to manage this up scale bed and breakfast.

    It would be a great place for residents to stow their overflow out of town company. It would be a great place for prospective property owners to stay while scouting out real estate in the area. I see it as a benefit for the community. It looks better than half the properties on Monument and it is good PR for our area.

    Regardless of my opinion or that of the original post, contact the property owners yourself and find out the details before showing up half cocked and uninformed at a Zoning or Council meeting. Let’s not be sheep, people!

    Fiona @ September 17th, 2007 at 9:30 am

  2. I agree with Fiona.

    I think it would be a bit reactionary to think a bed and breakfast is going to be the harbinger of 7-11’s and Starbucks.

    Funny thing is, I had this idea a couple of years ago after visiting a wonderful B&B in San Francisco’s Castro district. I wish the owners well and hope they are successful. Sounds like a dream life to me.

    e @ September 17th, 2007 at 10:28 am

  3. I’m not against bed & breakfasts. In the very same zoning document, an application was filed to open a bed and breakfast on Grove. They can add a lot to the community.

    I am against businesses on Monument. Business owners aren’t the only ones that refurbish houses - there are exterior remodels happening constantly up and down Monument.

    I guess people don’t realize what a rarity it is to have a purely residential environment on a major thouroughfare. It’s an oasis in the urban jungle. Maybe not for long.

    Sam @ September 17th, 2007 at 11:59 am

  4. I can only agree with the above comments. Monument Avenue isn’t Carytown; it’s a state and national historic district, with a raft of provisos and covenenants to prevent the very thing that has been happening on, say, Robinson Street with Starbucks. But even there, that was a business-oriented building with a parking lot. The building had sat there fallow for quite some time, and was then replaced by a video/tanning combination (which never made any sense to me).

    Harry @ September 17th, 2007 at 12:03 pm

  5. West of Boulevard now has two Council approved bed and breakfast locations as approved last September the 10th, last Monday.

    2811 Grove Avenue
    (ordinance 2007-224-196)

    3101 West Franklin Street
    (ordinance 2007-223-195)

    These ordinances authorize the special use of the property for the purpose of authorizing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling with tourist home lodging units, together with accessory parking, upon certain terms and conditions. (as per the city’s ordinance and resolution tracking system http://www.richmondgov.com/applications/clerksTracking/index.asp)

    Fiona @ September 18th, 2007 at 8:33 am

  6. I am not against bed and breakfast places. And I am for youth hostels.

    What’s interesting about this is where it potentially collides with “rooming house laws” that are designed to keep poor people from living together in big houses (like some of the giants on the Northside).

    A bed and breakfast sounds a lot better than a “crack house” (and no, I don’t think this “Maury Place” is in any danger of turning into a crack house), but legislating the differences along class and racial lines is worrisome.

    Tourism vs. affordable housing, anyone?

    Scott Burger @ September 18th, 2007 at 12:14 pm

  7. I have seen the business proposal; they intend to cater to nudists.

    Angie O'Plasty @ September 18th, 2007 at 1:43 pm

  8. I understand that they will do nude catering to their guests.

    Angie O'Plasty @ September 19th, 2007 at 10:48 am

  9. Nude catering sounds awesome or terrible? I can’t tell.

    Ross @ September 19th, 2007 at 12:26 pm

  10. [...] that Bed & Breakfast that was approved to operate at Monument and Belmont? Well, Maury Place has the approvals they need [...]

    West of the Boulevard News » Blog Archive » Bed & Breakfast on Monument now has a website @ November 12th, 2007 at 8:02 am

  11. [...] It looks like another B&B is set to open on Monument Ave. I’ve already said that I don’t think businesses belong on our most beloved byway. [...]

    West of the Boulevard News » Blog Archive » Another Bed and Breakfast on Monument Ave? @ December 18th, 2007 at 11:02 am

  12. I hope they do cater to nudists! I’m a nudist and I would love to check it out! I would be able to meet others!

    Bobby Helme @ April 28th, 2008 at 2:14 pm

Awards

Richmond 2k7 Blog Awards Nominee

Comments

  • Harry on City Council Agenda for Nov.24, items related to WOTB
  • Harry on Disappearing CBS Tower
  • Fiona on City Council Agenda for Nov.24, items related to WOTB
  • Daniel on City Council Agenda for Nov.24, items related to WOTB
  • Shelley on City Council Agenda for Nov.24, items related to WOTB
  • Fiona on $10 MM for Pump House Park?
  • Harry on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Harry on $10 MM for Pump House Park?
  • gus on $10 MM for Pump House Park?
  • daniel on All Binsted murder suspects in custody
  • Scott Burger on $10 MM for Pump House Park?
  • chase on $10 MM for Pump House Park?
  • Sam on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Scott Burger on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Liberty on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Fiona on Ginger Thai DOUBLING UP @ Carytown Seafood location
  • Shelley on What do you think of the blue street signs?
  • DMW on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Sam on Digital billboard lights up I-195
  • Dan on Digital billboard lights up I-195

Archives

Browse through our archives for these categories: spare change, features, news

Or go back in time:

Written work © 2008 under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 License, unless otherwise indicated.

PharrOut Logo